Take a look in the mirror and stop blaming other groups for trucking-related labor problems, says a new report by the Canadian Trucking Alliance.
The CTA Blue Ribbon Task Force on the Driver Shortage report aims to take a “comprehensive and honest attempt to tackle” the impending shortage of qualified commercial drivers in Canada. Much of the report should hit home for U.S. carriers, as well.
The key conclusions of the report are:
– Truck drivers are our most important asset, the face of the industry — to our customers and to the public, and they are deserving of respect.
– Truck drivers should have an improved ability to predict what their weekly pay is going to be; compensation packages need to be competitive with or better than alternative employment options and more transparent.
– Truck drivers should be paid for all the work that they do and earn enough to cover all reasonable out-of-pocket expenses incurred while on the road for extended periods.
– (Drivers’) time at work should not be wasted – at shipper/consignee premises, waiting for their trucks in the shop, or waiting for a response to a question of their carrier.
– (Drivers) should be able to rely on their carrier not to interfere with their personal time by (for example) calling them back to work early.
– Driver wellness should be a top priority for employers.
– A minimum standard of entry level, apprenticeship or apprenticeship-like truck driver training should be mandatory.
– Truck driving should be considered a skilled trade and be recognized as such by the various levels and branches of government, standards councils, etc., who certify such things.
“While the report highlights the usual “systemic issues” behind the shortage — such as driver demographics, public perceptions of the occupation, an unpopular lifestyle, not being deemed a skilled occupation and regulations — it also holds up a mirror to the industry and attempts to incite a national dialogue within the transportation community,” says the CTA in a press release.
The report purposefully does not shy away from discussing some of the more contentious issues linked to the driver shortage, including compensation (which the report says “is inescapably the overriding issue” that needs to be resolved) and the need for organized immigration strategies.
The report cites the “traditional ‘piece work’ pay system” as one of the key reasons for the driver shortage, explaining that it “places the burden of inefficiencies of the freight system created by others onto the backs of drivers” and states that compensation packages for truck drivers — especially long-haul operators — “are no longer competitive with other industries” competing with trucking for a shrinking labor pool.
While the report acknowledges that an hourly pay system may be a “relevant consideration” in some segments of the industry where driving is the sole function or in short-haul/city PD operations, it is not a solution for the industry at large.
The “reality is that drivers do inevitably arrive at some sort of per-hour calculation of what they are paid,” it concludes. “Carriers must be competitive with each other. The key is not necessarily how drivers are paid, but how much they are paid.”
At the same time, the industry needs to do a better job compensating drivers for additional work they do as well as make pay packages more transparent in order to help drivers predict what their pay will be from week to week, the report says.
In addition to demographics, compensation, and driver quality of life, driver qualification is also identified as one of the key underpinnings of the shortage. To address that, the core values contain the recommendation that “a minimum standard of entry level apprenticeship or apprenticeship-like truck driver training should be mandatory” and there should also be a program of “ongoing training and/or certification” throughout a driver’s career.
The report concedes there is merit – at least in the short-term – in the argument that a driver shortage is good for the industry in that it creates tightness in capacity which in turn places upward pressure on freight rates. The report acknowledges “there will be no quick fixes, no magic bullets” and that “in the short and medium-term, the situation and its resulting impact on capacity is unlikely to change.”
However, it contends that in the longer-term the capacity imbalance is not sustainable and that “the combination of a shrinking labor pool and economic growth will, at some point in the future, create a situation where the industry will not be able to meet the standards of service that have been the hallmark of trucking’s rise” to dominance.
This article originally appeared on www.todaystrucking.com. Used with permission.
Printer Friendly Version
Email This Story
Industry : Related News
4/13/2012 – Canadian Trucking Alliance Tells Carriers to Take Responsibility for Driver Shortage
Take a look in the mirror and stop blaming other groups for trucking-related labor problems, says a new report by the Canadian Trucking Alliance….
4/12/2012 – Fleet Advantage Promotes Kathy Ivanov to Senior VP, Administration
Fleet Advantage, provider of truck fleet business analytics and equipment financing, promoted Kathy Walkerow-Ivanov to senior vice president of administration….
4/12/2012 – Atlas Survey Shows Truckers’ “Favorite Things”
Drivers, at least those for a major moving company, are staying in touch via smartphones and Skype, like to eat at Subway and snack on fresh fruit, and would rather listen to classic rock than country, according to an annual survey….
4/12/2012 – Kenworth to Cut 10% of Jobs at Chillicothe Plant
The Chillicothe Gazette is reporting that Kenworth plans to lay off 10% of workers at its Chillicothe, Ohio plant on Monday….
4/12/2012 – Accuride to Expand Wheel Production at S.C. Plant
Accuride Corp., plans to expand aluminum wheel production capacity at its Camden, S.C.. plant….
4/11/2012 – Rolling Strong Introduces Wellness App
Rolling Strong introduced what it says is the first wellness app in the transportation industry. The RoadApp to Wellness is available on the iPhone, iPad or computers to help professional drivers get on the road to better health….
4/10/2012 – EEOC Seeks Rehearing for Trucker Harassment Case
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has filed a request for a federal appeals court to reconsider a ruling it says would hurt the EEOC’s ability to pursue class-action discrimination lawsuits for more than 100 women truck drivers claiming they were sexually harassed by male drivers…
4/9/2012 – Rolling Strong Driver Wellness Tour Takes to the Road
The 2012 Rolling Strong Driver Wellness Tour begins its nationwide appearances at nine Pilot Flying J locations beginning April 18 through Dec. 12….
4/9/2012 – New President for Quality Carriers
Quality Distribution Inc. has named Randall T. Strutz as president of its wholly owned subsidiary Quality Carriers Inc. Quality Carriers is the primary operating unit within the company’s chemical logistics business….
4/6/2012 – Jacobs Names Director of New Technology
Jacobs Vehicle Systems appointed Thomas Howell director of new technology….
4/6/2012 – Diamond International Breaks Ground for Springfield, Mo., Dealership
Diamond International of Springfield, Mo., a local International Truck dealership, held a groundbreaking ceremony on April 4 at 2635 East Diamond Street, the future home of the new facility….
4/6/2012 – Heavy-Duty Aftermarket Up Nearly 30%
Since the trough of the heavy-duty aftermarket in December 2009, U.S. parts sales have increased by 29.4%. …
4/6/2012 – Great Dane Breaks Ground on Engineering Technology Center
Expanding on the existing corporate office facility located at 602 E. Lathrop Ave. in Savannah, Ga., Great Dane has officially broken ground on the site of a brand new research and development campus….
4/6/2012 – Wabash National Helps with Indiana Tornado Relief
Wabash National Corp. loaned a semi-trailer to transport supplies for American Red Cross tornado relief efforts in southern Indiana after tornados devastated the area last month….
4/6/2012 – Survey Suggests ‘Connected Fleet’ is Becoming the Norm
GreenRoad‘s Fleet Leaders Survey shows that 57% of fleet leaders have “connected fleets” using Web-based fleet-management solutions. Twenty-eight percent of fleet leaders are actively using smartphones for fleet management today, and 8% are using iPads or tablet computers, the survey found….
4/5/2012 – Penske Names Senior Vice President of Marketing
Penske Truck Leasing has named Sherry Sanger as senior vice president of marketing….
4/5/2012 – Polar Service Centers Opens Location in Killdeer, N.D.
Polar Service Centers has opened a location in Killdeer, N.D., the heart of the Bakken Shale oilfields and one of the fastest-growing oil-producing areas in the country….
4/5/2012 – Great Dane Opens Statesboro, Ga., Manufacturing Plant
Little more than a year after breaking ground on its new refrigerated trailer manufacturing plant in Statesboro, Ga., the Great Dane facility opened for production this week….
4/5/2012 – Bar’s Products Names National Sales Manager
Max Douglas brings 40 years of automotive aftermarket industry sales and marketing experience to his new position as national sales manager for Bar’s Products, …
4/4/2012 – Used Trucks: Medium Duty Prices Stable, Heavy-Duty Buyers Wait for Natural Gas Options
For the past several months, the used medium-duty truck segment has been very stable, not moving much in either direction, says Ricky Beggs, managing editor at Black Book, which provides vehicle pricing information for the automotive industry….
4/4/2012 – Drivers Asked to Weigh in on CSA
The American Transportation Research Institute launched its second annual truck driver survey to identify CSA impacts on trucking operations, as well as driver perceptions and attitudes toward the maturing regulatory program….
4/4/2012 – 41% of Australian Truck Drivers Have Sleep Apnea, Study Says
A new sleep study found that 41% of Australian truck drivers have obstructive sleep apnea….
4/3/2012 – Trucker Buddy Elects New Officers, Board Members
The executive committee and board of directors of Trucker Buddy International have named new officers and members….
4/3/2012 – Azure Dynamics, Maker of Transit Connect Electric, Seeks Bankruptcy Protection
Beset by slow sales and serious financial hardship, Azure Dynamics, a maker of electric and hybrid trucks, has declared bankruptcy and shut down most of its operations….
4/3/2012 – FleetPride Names Lee Stockseth President and COO
FleetPride promoted Lee Stockseth to president and COO. He will continue to report to W. M. McGee, chairman and CEO….
4/2/2012 – Meritor Makes Key Personnel Changes in Aftermarket Division
Meritor, Inc. has appointed Craig Cartmill to the position of vice president, Aftermarket Americas, and Doug Wolma, general manager, Global Aftermarket Operations….
4/2/2012 – LMTA Initiates Program to Cultivate Trucking Leadership in Louisiana
The Louisiana Motor Transport Association has established a leadership training program that helps develop state leadership to meet future challenges and growth in the transportation industry….
4/2/2012 – Trucker Buddies of the Month Honored at MATS
LOUISVILLE, KY — Twelve Trucker Buddies were honored at the Mid-America Trucking Show in March. The drivers were selected based on nominations from their classes and teachers highlighting their dedication to excellence of the Trucker Buddy program. …
3/30/2012 – Telogis Acquires Maptuit
Telogis Inc. has acquired Maptuit, a provider of connected navigation for commercial fleets….
3/30/2012 – Love’s Travel Stop Opens in Comfort, Texas
Love’s Travel Stops opened a new travel stop in Comfort, Texas, at Interstate 10, Exit 523….
3/30/2012 – International Used Truck Centers Launch Prostar Maxxforce Sweepstakes
International Used Truck Centers is holding the “Get Used to International” ProStar MaxxForce Sweepstakes with the grand prize being a 2010 International ProStar used truck with a MaxxForce 13 engine and 12-month, 100,000-mile powertrain warranty….
3/29/2012 – Wabash Plans Purchase of Walker Group, a Major Tanker Manufacturer
Wabash National Corp. has agreed to buy Walker Group Holdings, which owns Brenner, Garlite, Progress, Tri-State Tank and other builders of tank trailers, truck bodies and engineered systems for the chemical and pharmaceutical industries….
3/28/2012 – Diamond International Completes Renovation and Expansion in Russellville, Ark.
To support business growth and service innovations, Diamond International of Russellville, a local International Truck dealership, has completed the final phase of a $2.5 million expansion….
3/28/2012 – Haldex Expands Remanufactured and Friction Product Management Team
Haldex has added Tim Shaw as product manager for all remanufactured products produced in the Marion, N.C. remanufacturing plant, and Dan Dunkleberger joined Haldex as product manager for friction products and remanufactured brake shoes….
3/28/2012 – Detroit Diesel Renames Detroit Diesel Genuine Parts
Detroit Diesel Corp. is re-naming the Detroit Diesel Genuine Parts brand to Detroit Genuine Parts. The former Detroit Diesel Reliabilt brand will be folded into the Detroit Genuine Parts brand as well….
3/27/2012 – Green Truck Association Announces Three Technology Councils
The Green Truck Association, an affiliate division of the National Truck Equipment Association, has formed three technology councils to better represent specific segments within the green truck industry….
3/26/2012 – Universal Lubricants Launches Initiative to Convert Fleets to Re-refined Engine Oils
Universal Lubricants announced an initiative to educate fleets about the benefits of re-refined engine oils….
3/26/2012 – FleetPride Opens Location in Cincinnati
FleetPride opened a new location in Cincinnati, located at 2514 Commerce Blvd….
3/23/2012 – Pilot Flying J Acquires Travel Plaza in Alexandria, Minn.
Pilot Flying J acquired a travel plaza in Alexandria, Minn., at 3181 Evergreen Lane off Interstate 94 at Exit 100. It will remain open during remodeling, which is expected to be complete in July 2012….
3/23/2012 – TCA Highway Angel Helps Man Having Heart Attack
The Truckload Carriers Association‘s latest Highway Angel is Jonathan “AZ” Atzenhofer, a professional truck driver for FTC Transportation Inc. of Oklahoma City….
3/23/2012 – Vipar Heavy Duty Names James McGuire Director of Business Development
Vipar Heavy Duty named James McGuire director of business development with responsibility for stockholder development in the Central U.S….
3/22/2012 – IdleAir Opens New Site in Benson, Ariz.
IdleAir has opened a new location in Benson, Ariz. next to Love’s at Exit 302 off of I-10….
3/22/2012 – ‘2020 Super Truck’ Wins Freightliner Design Contest on Facebook
LOUISVILLE, KY — Swoopy styling and interior innovations by a young art student won Freightliner Trucks’ Future of Pride Profit design contest, conducted over the last four months strictly on Facebook….
3/21/2012 – CARB Urges Truckers to Report Vehicles Before March 30 Deadline
The California Air Resources Board is reminding California-bound truck owners that the deadline to report information regarding their fleets has been extended to March 30….
3/21/2012 – Highway Angel Honored for Helping Woman with Diabetes
The Truckload Carriers Associationnamed Jonathan W. Bennett, a professional truck driver for Walden Haulers Group Inc., Harriman, Tenn., its latest Highway Angel….
3/21/2012 – Wabco Appoints VP, Americas and VP, Compression and Braking
Wabco Holdings Inc. announced appointed Nikhil Varty to the newly created position of vice president, Americas and mergers acquisitions, reporting to the CEO….
3/21/2012 – FleetPride Opens Fourth Utah Location
FleetPride has opened a new 8,000-square-foot location in Ogden, Utah, its fourth location in the state….
3/19/2012 – HDT Wins Business Journalism Award
Heavy Duty Trucking Editor-in-Chief Deborah Lockridge was named a Neal Award winner today by American Business Media during the 58th Annual Jesse H. Neal National Business Journalism Awards ceremony Friday in New York City, for her article, “9 Ways to Keep Cargo Safe Secure” in the July 2011 issue of HDT….
3/19/2012 – Women-Owned Businesses to be Identified on Load Board
Internet Truckstop, with help from the Women In Trucking Association, launched a program that will designate women-owned businesses on the truckstop.com load board….
3/19/2012 – NationaLease President Scoggins Retires
Gene Scoggins, president of NationaLease, is retiring after a 37-year career in transportation. …
3/19/2012 – TRALA Elects Tom Brown of Brown NationaLease as 2012-2013 Chairman
Tom Brown, president of Brown NationaLease in Des Moines, Iowa, was unanimously chosen by the members of the Truck Renting and Leasing Association as 2012-2013 chairman…
3/16/2012 – Travel Centers of America Sees Losses for 4Q, Gains for the Year
For the 2011 fourth quarter, Travel Centers of America had a net loss of $2.5 million. This is, however, an improvement compared to the net loss of $30 million in the 2010 fourth quarter….
3/16/2012 – Wingfoot Opens Truck Care Center in Arizona
Wingfoot Commercial Systems, a subsidiary of The Goodyear Tire Rubber Company , expanded its on-highway service network with a Wingfoot Truck Care Center in Winslow, Ariz….
3/16/2012 – Kinedyne Expands Management Team
Kinedyne Corp. announced three additions to its team. All three men were most recently with Ancra International….
3/16/2012 – Allison Transmission Shares Rise in First Day
Allison Transmission Holdings Inc.’s shares rose the day of their debut after falling earlier in the day….
3/16/2012 – TRALA Funds Vocational Scholarship Program
The Truck Renting and Leasing Association plans to launch the TRALA Industry Scholarship Program….
3/15/2012 – AME Hires Aftermarket Sales Manager
AME International, manufacturer of tire changing tools and equipment, hired Rob Henwood as heavy duty aftermarket sales manager….
3/15/2012 – FleetPride Acquires Trane’s Diesel Service
FleetPride acquired the assets of Trane’s Diesel Service in Idaho Falls, Idaho….
3/15/2012 – Driver Named Highway Angel for Chain-up Help
The Truckload Carriers Association announced its latest Highway Angel is professional truck driver Mike Mozley of Kool Pak, Lake Oswego, Ore….
3/14/2012 – Ancra Promotes Larocque to Managing Director, Ancra Canada
Ancra International promoted Brian Larocque to managing director of Ancra Canada….
3/13/2012 – Alapont to Retire as Federal-Mogul President and CEO
Jose Maria Alapont will retire as the president and CEO of Federal-Mogul Corp. on March 31. …
3/13/2012 – HDT Announces 2012 Truck Fleet Innovators
Newport Business Media announced its 2012 HDT Truck Fleet Innovators. Since 2006, each year the editors of Heavy Duty Trucking have honored a group of select industry leaders for their innovation in various areas….
3/12/2012 – Bridgestone Launches Project to Develop Sustainable Source of Natural Rubber
Bridgestone Corp. has plans for a research project in the U.S. to develop the Guayule plant as a commercially viable, renewable source of high-quality natural rubber….
3/9/2012 – Love’s Donates $25,000 to Red Cross for Tornado Disaster Relief
Love’s Travel Stops will donate $25,000 to the American Red Cross, Louisville, Ky., regional chapter to help communities in the Southern Indiana and Kentucky areas struck by tornadoes on March 2….
3/9/2012 – Great Dane Promotes Three Engineers
Great Dane promoted three members of its Savannah, Ga., engineering management team, Charlie Fetz, Adam Hill and Alan Whiten….
3/8/2012 – Pilot Flying J Acquires Travel Plaza in Northfield, Minn.
Pilot Flying J acquired a travel plaza in Northfield, Minn., located at 8051 Bagley Ave. off Interstate 35 at Exit 69. It will remain open during remodeling, which is expected to be complete in May….
3/8/2012 – NTEA Installs Frank Livas as 48th President
Frank Livas, president of Brake Clutch, Salem, Mass., was installed as the 48th president of the NTEA, the Association for the Work Truck Industry….
3/8/2012 – TCA Members Honored for
At its annual convention this week, the Truckload Carriers Association paid tribute to the “Ambassador Club” companies who have held longtime memberships….
3/8/2012 – Parker Reports Positive Results for RunWise Hybrid Drive System
Parker Hannifin confirmed a 43% reduction in fuel consumption and 99% uptime for refuse vehicles using its RunWise Advanced Series Hybrid Drive System after more than a year of service for its fleet of pre-production vehicles operating in several communities in South Florida….
3/8/2012 – CARB Offers New Leasing Option for Cleaner Trucks
The California Air Resources Board is now offering a lease-to-own financing opportunity to encourage early compliance with CARB’s on-road diesel vehicle and tractor-trailer greenhouse gas regulations….
3/8/2012 – Robert Low Elected TCA Chairman
The Truckload Carriers Association has a new chairman: Robert Low, president and founder of Prime Inc., Springfield, Mo. Low, who will serve for the 2012-2013 term, was sworn in during TCA’s Annual Convention in Orlando, Fla., this week….
3/7/2012 – Motor Carrier Service, Paramount Freight Named 2012 Best Fleets to Drive For
Motor Carrier Service, Northwood, Ohio, and Paramount Freight Systems, Ft. Myers, Fla., are the overall winners of the fourth annual “Best Fleets to Drive For” survey and contest….
3/7/2012 – Professional Truck Driver Institute Recognizes Longtime Employee Marlene Dakita
ORLANDO, FL — The Professional Truck Driver Institute awarded its 14th annual Lee J. Crittenden Memorial Award to Marlene Dakita, the organization’s long-time certification coordinator, during the Truckload Carriers Association annual convention….
3/7/2012 – Joyce Brenny Receives 2012 “Influential Woman in Trucking” Award
Joyce Brenny, owner of Brenny Transportation and Brenny Specialized, received the second annual “Influential Woman in Trucking” award at the Truckload Carriers Association‘s annual meeting yesterday….
3/7/2012 – ATA’s Bill Graves to Address Technology Challenges at Pegasus TransTech User Conference
ATA President and CEO Bill Graves will address recent accomplishments in transportation technology by the ATA and the American Transportation Research Institute in his keynote at the Pegasus TransTech Users Conference in Clearwater, Fla., on April 18….
3/7/2012 – Accuride Chairman Stepping Down; Company Names VP/CFO
William M. Lasky, chairman of Accuride Corp.‘s board of directors, has decided not to stand for re-election at the company’s annual meeting of stockholders on April 24, 2012….
3/7/2012 – Pat Quinn Receives Posthumous TCA Past Chairmen’s Award
The Truckload Carriers Association presented its Past Chairmen’s Award posthumously to Pat Quinn, co-chairman and president of U.S. Xpress Enterprises, Chattanooga, Tenn….
3/6/2012 – Bendix Spicer Foundation Brake Adds to Executive Team
Eddie Wilkinson was appointed president of Bendix Spicer Foundation Brake, a joint venture of Bendix Commercial Vehicle Systems and Dana Commercial Vehicle Products
3/6/2012 – Vanguard Truck Centers Opens Georgia Volvo Location
Vanguard Truck Centers opened its newest full-service Volvo Truck location in Adairsville, Ga….
3/6/2012 – Penske Opens Collision Repair Center in Maryland
Penske Truck Leasing has opened its 17th truck collision repair center, in Annapolis Junction, Md….
3/6/2012 – Ervin Equipment Joins Wabash, Transcraft Dealer Networks
Ervin Equipment joined the dealer network for both Wabash National and its subsidiary, Transcraft….
3/6/2012 – Ancra Promotes Jim Calico to Executive VP
Ancra International promoted Jim Calico to executive vice president of sales and marketing….
3/5/2012 – Poll Explores Transportation Workers’ Sleep Habits
Nearly half of truck drivers in a recently survey say they rarely or never get a good night’s sleep, but that’s not much worse than non-transportation workers and better than train operators and pilots….
3/5/2012 – Superior Distributors Marks 50 Years of Business
Superior Distributors Inc. in Elmwood Park, N.J., is celebrating its 50th year in business….
3/2/2012 – NAFA Announces Beyond Fleet Campaign for Fleet Managers
NAFA Fleet Management Association‘s new Beyond Fleet campaign seeks to gain executive level recognition for fleet managers, educate fleet managers on their value and worth to their employers and equip fleet managers with the tools they need to sell and promote themselves to their employers….
3/2/2012 – Navistar Honors Perdue Farms for Innovative Partnership
Navistar and Barr International Trucks of Salisbury, Md., awarded Perdue Farms a Strategic Partnership Award for collaborating on truck fleet innovations, including an ultra-lightweight tractor specification and fully integrated tractor-trailer electronic controls….
3/1/2012 – Cummins Westport Names Jim Arthurs President
Jim Arthurs, former vice president, Westport Cryogenic Systems, is the new president of Cummins Westport….
3/1/2012 – PacLease Opens Seven Franchises in Midwest and Pacific Northwest
Paccar Leasing will open seven new locations in the Midwest and Pacific Northwest as it continues to expand its franchise network in the United States….
3/1/2012 – 30th Anniversary Shell Rotella SuperRigs to be Held in Joplin, Mo.
The 30th Anniversary Shell Rotella SuperRigs will take place May 17-19 at the Speedco in Joplin, Mo….
3/1/2012 – Cooper Teams up with Company to Find New Polymers for Tires
Cooper Tire Rubber Company and Yulex Corp. have signed an agreement to jointly work on developing guayule polymers and resins for tire applications….
3/1/2012 – Westport Reports Higher Revenues, Net Loss
Westport Innovations reported a net loss of $14.5 million ($0.30 loss per share) for the quarter and a net loss of $60.1 million for the first nine months of its fiscal year (a $1.26 loss per share)….