The proposed rule would require electronic onboard recorders for all of the approximately 500,000 carriers now required to maintain driver logbooks.By Oliver B. Patton, Washington Editor
The new proposal on electronic onboard reporters vastly expands the rule the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration put out less than a year ago.
The current rule, which will go into effect June 4, 2012, says that carriers that violate hours of service rules 10 percent of the time, based on single compliance review, must use electronic onboard recorders to track driver hours. It will affect only 5,700 interstate carriers.
The rule the agency is now proposing, which will go into effect three years after it is made final, will cover all of the approximately 500,000 carriers now required to maintain driver logs. It will not apply to short-haul interstate carriers that use timecards to document hours of service.
The proposal also covers requirements for documentation to prove compliance with the hours of service rule, and it would require carriers to monitor driver compliance with the rule.
In cases where drivers mainly use timecards but occasionally drive beyond the limits of their normal operations, the agency said it would permit continued use of timecards. The agency considered extending the recorder requirement to short-haul drivers of bulk hazmats, but decided to study the issue further and is looking for comments.
The agency said it considered requiring recorders just for long-haul operations outside the 150 air-mile radius, but decided that would not address safety concerns associated with short-haul carriers that use driver logs. It is asking for comments on whether a long-haul option is feasible, however.
Another possibility the agency looked at was the universal approach recommended by the National Transportation Safety Board – all motor carriers. But the cost of such a requirement would have exceeded the benefits for most short-haul carriers, the agency found.
The cost of a life
On this point, the agency was working with a crucial new piece of information. In drafting its rules, the agency is required to balance costs and benefits. A key data point in that equation is Economic Value of a Statistical Life. In 2008 the Department of Transportation raised that figure – doubled it, in fact – from $3 million to $6 million.
This change gave the agency more leeway to expand the recorder rule. The agency also noted in yesterday’s proposal that the broader mandate is more cost-effective because the industry is making more use of onboard communications and management systems.
FMCSA said it does not expect to change the 2012 compliance date for the current rule, even though the final rule arising from this proposal should be done before then. It will enforce the current rule during the period between the 2012 compliance date and the compliance date of the new rule, the agency said.
The agency said it was considering the costs of recorders when it came up with the three-year grace period for compliance.
It estimates that the annualized cost for a carrier that does not already use a fleet management or other EOBR-ready system ranges from $525 to $785 per tractor. For a carrier with an EOBR-ready system in place, the cost would be $92.
But the aggregate impact of the mandate will be significant, considering the large number of small carriers, the agency said. Hence the three-year window.
The agency asks for comments on this point, and indicated it will consider adjustments to the compliance date. It also is asking for comments on the idea of staggering the adoption schedule by requiring larger carriers to make the move first.
With respect to supporting documents, the proposal includes a requirement that carriers maintain an hours of service management system – controls, policies, programs, practices and procedures that systematically monitor a driver’s compliance with the rules, and verify the accuracy of the logs. Failure to maintain such a system would be listed as an acute and critical citation.
Here’s a rundown on other aspects of the supporting documents proposal:
* The driver’s name or identification number. A vehicle number could be used as long as it can be associated with a driver at a specific date, time and location.
* The date of an event, and the time the event began and ended.
* The location must be precise enough for enforcement personnel to quickly find it on a map. If the location, which can be the nearest city or town, comes from an electronic document, it must derive from a source that no one can alter. The agency is proposing to prohibit electronic jamming devices that interfere with EOBRs.
* The number of documents that carriers will need to maintain will vary according to the operational circumstances, the agency said.
* Regarding the type of documents, the agency said it will require four categories: payroll, trip-related expense records and receipts, communications logs from fleet management systems, and a bill of lading or its equivalent.
* The agency is proposing to allow carriers to provide just one supporting document for the beginning and end of each on-duty not-driving period, provided the document contains all the data elements. If it does not, the carrier would have to keep enough documents to show collectively the required information.
In addition the agency is proposing a provision that would allow a carrier to certify that none of the required supporting documents are available. This should not be seen as a loophole, the agency cautioned: “Motor carriers that falsely certify the absence of supporting documents would be subject to the maximum penalty authorized by law.”
The retention period for supporting documents would be six months.
David Osiecki, senior vice president for policy and regulatory affairs at American Trucking Associations, said he was not surprised by the scope of the agency’s proposal. “It is what we expected,” he said.
The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association said in a statement that EOBRs cannot accurately record driver hours and duty status. The association also warned that recorders can be used to harass drivers.
The proposal can be found at http://www.ofr.gov/OFRUpload/OFRData/2011-02093_PI.pdf. The agency will be accepting comments as soon as the proposal is published in the Federal Register.
Government/Regulations: Related News
2/1/2011 – New Proposal Would Greatly Expand EOBR Use
The new proposal on electronic onboard reporters vastly expands the rule the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration put out less than a year ago….
1/31/2011 – Judge Puts Minnesota Fatigue Program to Sleep
A U.S. District Court judge has ruled that the Minnesota State Patrol’s use of CVSA Level III inspections to determine fatigue violates truckers’ Fourth Amendment rights….
1/31/2011 – FMCSA Proposes EOBR Mandate for All Interstate Drivers
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is proposing that all interstate trucks and buses be equipped with electronic onboard recorders to track driver hours….
1/28/2011 – PHMSA Proposes Flammables Ban in Wetlines
The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration has proposed a rule that would prohibit transport of flammable liquids in the pipes beneath cargo tanks….
1/28/2011 – Fatigue Study Provides Basis for 34-Hour Restart Proposal
The 34-hour restart gives daytime drivers a chance to catch up on their rest, but it does not work as well for night drivers. In fact, it may even be detrimental to driver performance.
That’s the conclusion of a study the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is using to justify its proposal that the restart include two periods of rest between midnight and 6 a.m….
1/28/2011 – Canada Rolls Out New Road Safety Strategy
Canada’s Ministers Responsible for Transportation and Highway Safety have approved a new five-year Road Safety Strategy under which Canada will continue to strive to have the safest roads in the world….
1/28/2011 – FMCSA to Hold Public Listening Session on Hours-of-Service Proposed Rule
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced today that it will hold a public listening session on its hours-of-service proposal Feb. 17 in Arlington, Va….
1/25/2011 – ATRI Suggests Alternative Approach to Safety Compliance
A trucking industry research group has put together a concept for how carriers might improve their safety performance without following traditional compliance requirements….
1/24/2011 – ATA Mounts Assault on HOS Proposal
American Trucking Associations is gearing up a multi-front campaign to stop the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s proposal to change the hours of service rules….
1/24/2011 – New York DOT Official Charged with Accepting Bribes
A DOT official in New York State has been charged with taking bribes from the trucking companies he was supposed to be inspecting….
1/19/2011 – President Signs Executive Order Addressing Regulation Concerns
While speakers at a heavy-duty aftermarket event in Las Vegas were discussing how concern about government regulations has given business pause, President Obama yesterday signed an executive order aimed at tackling criticism that regulations are stifling business and the economy….
1/17/2011 – Legal Fight Against EOBRs Proceeds
With a proposal to expand the requirement for electronic onboard recorders pending in the regulatory pipeline, owner-operators are fighting a legal action against the limited recorder requirement that is scheduled to take effect next year….
1/13/2011 – Cell-phone and Texting Laws Compiled
The American Trucking Associations State Laws Newsletter is reporting that rhe Governors Highway Safety Association has issued a compilation of state laws that limit or prohibit drivers’ use of cell phones or texting….
1/11/2011 – CSA Materials Available at Truckstops
Beginning January 12, brochures and pocket cards about the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s new CSA enforcement program will be available for commercial motor vehicle drivers at hundreds of travel centers across the country….
1/11/2011 – Florida Extends Ease on Trucking Regs Through Jan 14
To give growers more time to haul their crops to packing facilities, Florida Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam is extending an executive order relaxing trucking restrictions through Jan. 14….
1/11/2011 – NC/VA Reciprocity Agreement Cancelled
The American Trucking Associations State Laws Newsletter is reporting that effective January 21, 2011, a permitting reciprocity agreement between North Carolina and Virginia will be cancelled….
1/7/2011 – OOIDA Says Mexican Border Deal Cost American Jobs, Provides No Reciprocal Benefits
The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association responded to the Obama Administration’s overture to the Mexican truckers saying if the proposed deal goes through, American drivers will lose work to Mexican carriers who do not bear similar compliance costs….
1/4/2011 – NHTSA Clears Path for Speed-Limiter Proposal
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is moving ahead on a rulemaking on speed limiters for heavy trucks, which had its start four years ago with petitions by two trucking interest groups….
12/31/2010 – OOIDA Wonders Why Speed Limiters Get the Green Light While Driver Training Standards Languish
An announcement to consider speed limiting heavy trucks to 68 mph has small business truckers wondering why this unproven science is moving forward while minimum training standards for drivers are still not on the books….
12/30/2010 – NHTSA to Begin Speed Limiter Rulemaking
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is going to begin a rulemaking that could lead to mandatory speed limiters on heavy trucks, as requested by American Trucking Associations and Road Safe America….
12/30/2010 – HOS Proposal Seems Likely to Lead to More Litigation
Early reaction to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s proposed changes in the hours of service rule indicates that the rule is likely to remain in litigation.
It is not clear what the proposed changes will do for safety. The agency says they will make trucking safer. The safety advocacy community says they do not go nearly far enough. The trucking industry says they go too far….
12/29/2010 – FMCSA Proposes Seven Changes in Hours Rule
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is proposing seven changes in the current hours of service rules in order to, it says, give drivers the flexibility to take a break during the day and reduce the health and safety risks of long hours of work….
12/29/2010 – Safety Group says New HOS Proposal Doesn’t Go Far Enough, Canadians say it Could Have Been Worse
Reaction to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration latest HOS proposal isn’t exactly inspiring….
12/27/2010 – NY Judge Blocks Diesel-retrofit Mandate
A New York Supreme Court judge recently blocked a Department of Environmental Conservation mandate requiring the owners of heavy-duty diesel vehicles to retrofit their fleets with costly new equipment….
12/23/2010 – FMCSA Posts Proposed HOS Revisions
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has posted long-awaited proposed revisions to the hours of service rule….
12/22/2010 – Trucking Groups Say Port Registries Violate Federal Law
The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA), the New Jersey Motor Truck Association and the Port Drivers Federation 18 have filed a petition asking the Department of Transportation (DOT) for a determination that mandatory drayage truck registries conducted by various ports and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) are pre-empted by federal law….
12/22/2010 – U.S. DOT Releases Latest “Faces of Distracted Driving” Video
U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood today released the latest video in the Department of Transportation’s “Faces of Distracted Driving” series….
12/20/2010 – Hours Proposal Cleared by OMB
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s hours of service proposal was cleared by the Office of Management and Budget on Friday, which means that it is on track to be published before the end of the year as the agency expects….
12/20/2010 – FMCSA Proposes Middle Approach to Cell Phone Restriction
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has chosen the middle path in its proposal to restrict cell phone use by commercial drivers.
The proposal essentially says that truck and bus drivers could only use a hands-free phone while driving. It would prohibit a driver from reaching for, dialing or holding a mobile phone while the truck is moving….
12/20/2010 – Heavy Trucks Forced back onto Maine State Highways
As of midnight Friday Dec. 17, the legal limit weight limit on I-295, I-395 and portions of I-95 dropped back to 80,000 pounds following the failure of the Senate to pass the $1.1 trillion 2011 omnibus budget bill….
12/20/2010 – PacLease to Host Webinar on Lease Accounting Changes for Private Fleet Operators
PacLease will hold a webinar on Jan. 6, 2011, to discuss proposed new lease accounting standards that will be finalized later in the year. The webinar is geared for private fleet operators….