A Wayne State University study published in the January 2012 issue of the journal Epidemiology points out that two influential early studies of cellphone use and crash risk may have overestimated the relative risk of conversation on cellphones while driving.
In this new study, Richard Young, Ph.D., professor of research in Wayne State University’s Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neurosciences in the School of Medicine, examined possible bias in a 1997 Canadian study and a 2005 Australian study. These earlier studies used cellphone billing records of people who had been in a crash and compared their cellphone use just before the crash to the same time period the day (or week) before – the control window.
Young said the issue with these studies is that people may not have been driving during the entire control window period, as assumed by the earlier study investigators.
“Earlier case-crossover studies likely overestimated the relative risk for cellphone conversations while driving by implicitly assuming that driving during a control window was full time when it may have been only part time,” said Young. “This false assumption makes it seem like cellphone conversation is a bigger crash risk than it really is.”
In Young’s new study, his research team used Global Positioning Satellite (GPS) data to track day-to-day driving of more than 400 drivers during a 100-day period. He then divided the days into pairs, with the first day representing the “control” day and the second day representing the “crash” day in the earlier studies. Overall, the team found little driving consistency in any given clock time period between the two days — driving time on the control day was only about one-fourth of the driving time on the crash day, during any specific clock time period.
“This underestimation of the amount of driving in the control windows by nearly four times could reduce cellphone conversation time in that control period,” Young said. “It makes it appear that there is less cellphone conversation in control periods than in the time just before a crash, making the relative risk estimate appear greater than it really is.”
Young found that when the cellphone conversation time in the control window was adjusted for the amount of driving, the amount of cellphone usage in the control window was about the same as in the minutes before a crash. He concluded that the crash risk for cellphone conversation while driving is one-fourth of what was claimed in previous studies, or near that of normal baseline driving.
Young added that many well-controlled studies with real driving show that the primary increase in crash risk from portable electronic devices comes from tasks that require drivers to look at the device or operate it with their hands, such as texting while driving. Five other recent real-world studies concur with his conclusion that the crash risk from cellular conversations is not greater than that of driving with no conversation.
“Tasks that take a driver’s eyes off the road or hands off the steering wheel are what increase crash risk,” said Young. “Texting, emailing, manual dialing and so forth — not conversation — are what increase the risk of crashes while driving.”
The National Transportation Safety Board has recommended that all 50 states and the District of Columbia ban the non-emergency use of portable electronic devices for all drivers. Young said this recommendation goes beyond the data from newer studies, including his, because it would ban cellphone conversations while driving.
“Recent real-world studies show that cellphone conversations do not increase crash risk beyond that of normal driving — it is the visual-manual tasks that take the eyes off the road and the hands off the wheel that are the real risk,” said Young.
Safety Security: Related News
12/28/2011 – Study: Early Cellphone Safety Studies Likely Overestimated Crash Risk
A Wayne State University study published in the January 2012 issue of the journal Epidemiology points out that two influential early studies of cellphone use and crash risk may have overestimated the relative risk of conversation on cellphones while driving….
12/27/2011 – Second Fatal Wheel-off Raises Questions About Truck Safety in Ontario
A woman driving a Honda Civic was killed by a flying truck wheel near Hamilton, Ont. on Thursday. It was the province’s second fatal wheel-off incident in as many weeks….
12/22/2011 – Small Georgia Fleet Owner Indicted for Violating OOS, Chameleon Carrier Charge
A man who apparently reincarnated an out-of-service trucking company — and allegedly kept operating after the chameleon company also was put out of service — has been indicted on federal charges….
12/22/2011 – Lexis-Nexis Report Highlights Potential Problem Areas in Driver Safety and Screening
A new study finds commercial driver applications with incomplete or inaccurate information increased 20% in 2011, pointing to an area fleets can target to improve safety and compliance….
12/22/2011 – Holiday Season Prime Time for Cargo Theft
Cargo thieves don’t take time off during the holidays — in fact, they may turn to more aggressive methods, say freight security experts….
12/12/2011 – NTSB to Review 2010 Multi-vehicle Crash in Missouri
The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) will hold a Board meeting to determine the probable cause, and consider proposed safety recommendations on the August 5, 2010, multi-vehicle highway accident in Gray Summit,
12/9/2011 – Highway Fatalities Drop, Truck-related Deaths Rise
Preliminary 2010 fatality and injury data shows that highway deaths fell to 32,885 for the year, the lowest level since 1949. The data also revealed that truck-related fatalities increased by nearly nine percent to 3,675….
12/9/2011 – TSA Recalls Improperly Encoded TWIC Cards
The integrated circuit chips on approximately 26,000 previously issued Transportation Worker Identification Credentials (TWICs) issued prior to April 5, 2011 were improperly encoded and may not work with TWIC card readers….
11/22/2011 – National Motorists Association Throws Down the Gauntlet on Red Light Cameras
The National Motorists Association (NMA) is challenging cities to do away with ticket-producing red-light cameras and replace them with traffic engineering solutions to combat red-light running. They’re putting $10,000 on the table that says safety can be improved without tickets….
11/22/2011 – FreightWatch Warns of Increased Incidents of Cargo Theft over Thanksgiving Weekend
Last year, FreightWatch reported that cargo crime increases by 28% over holiday periods and that Thanksgiving weekend recorded the most cargo theft activity of all holiday periods in the United States….
11/17/2011 – Safety Improvements Show HOS Rule Does Not Need Revision, ATA Says
The continuing improvement in truck safety shows that the current hours of service rules do not need to be revised, American Trucking Associations President Bill Graves said in a letter to the White House Office of Management and Budget….
11/17/2011 – Brake Safety Week Results Show Improvement in Brake Adjustment Rates, Increased Overall OOS Rates
Enforcement data gathered from across the continent during Operation Air Brake’s Brake Safety Week reveals the number of out-of-service defects for both brake adjustment and brake components are down slightly, while the overall OOS rate for brakes rose….
11/15/2011 – Cyclist Tragedy Sparks Side Guard Debate in Canada
Olivia Chow thinks all trucks need side guards on their trailers and she is introducing a bill in Canada’s Parliament to try to make it a reality….